Kentucky Dropped From AP Top 25 After 17-Point Comeback Win at South Carolina

COLUMBIA, S.C. — Kentucky football pulled off the largest road comeback in program history on Saturday night, storming back from 17 points down to beat South Carolina 35-34 in overtime at Williams-Brice Stadium. And for its trouble, the Wildcats dropped out of the AP Top 25 entirely. Welcome to October in the SEC, where a historic win can still cost you your ranking.

Here is the contradiction that defined Kentucky’s strange Sunday: the Wildcats received 160 points in the new AP Top 25 released Sunday afternoon — two points behind Pittsburgh, which claimed the No. 25 spot with 162. Two points. One ballot line. That was the difference between staying ranked and falling out after one of the wildest wins the program has ever produced. As ClutchPoints put it in its Sunday coverage, Kentucky’s spot in the AP Top 25 was stolen.

But the coaches saw it differently. In the Coaches Poll released the same day, Kentucky entered the Top 25 at No. 25, climbing two spots from receiving votes into the rankings. Two polls, one wild afternoon in Columbia, and two completely different verdicts on a 4-1 football team that owns a road overtime win in one of the SEC’s loudest stadiums.

Two Polls, Two Verdicts

The AP snub stings precisely because of how Kentucky won. This was not a sleepy non-conference blowout. This was a conference road game in which the Wildcats fell behind 17-0 less than four minutes into the second quarter, then clawed their way back across nearly four full quarters of SEC football. For context on just how improbable the comeback was: under former coach Mark Stoops, Kentucky was 0-49 when trailing by more than 14 points. Under first-year head coach Will Stein, the Wildcats are already 1-1 in such games.

Not everyone in the AP electorate agreed that was worth dropping Kentucky. Prominent voter Brett McMurphy had the Wildcats at No. 21 on his ballot, per A Sea of Blue’s Sunday rankings roundup, and CBS Sports’ Chip Patterson slotted Kentucky at No. 24. But the collective math fell two points short, and the Wildcats landed on the outside of the poll — ranked, in spirit, at No. 26.

The Coaches Poll, meanwhile, moved Kentucky up two spots into No. 25. If there is a lesson in the split decision, it is this: the AP voters watched the same game and decided the Wildcats did not deserve to keep their place; the coaches watched and gave them a bump. Both polls agree on one thing, though — Kentucky’s next opponent is legit. LSU sits at No. 10 in the Coaches Poll as the Wildcats prepare to welcome the Tigers to Lexington.

How the Comeback Happened

The afternoon started about as badly as a road trip can start. South Carolina, desperate at 2-3 and winless in the SEC, jumped on Kentucky early and built that 17-0 lead in the blink of an eye. Williams-Brice was shaking. The Wildcats looked dead in the water.

Then, per the Courier-Journal’s game report, the defense finally stiffened. Jordan Castell forced a fumble that swung momentum back toward the visitor sideline, and Zouagui drilled a 42-yard field goal to cut the deficit to 20-10 at halftime. The hole was still deep, but Kentucky had a pulse.

Quarterback Kenny Minchey, who would finish with 272 passing yards and three touchdowns, kept the Wildcats in it after the break. Late in the third quarter, he found Nic Anderson for a 32-yard touchdown that pulled Kentucky within 24-20. The rally was real. But South Carolina quarterback LaNorris Sellers was not finished — he answered with a fourth-quarter touchdown pass to retake the lead and put the pressure right back on the Wildcats.

Minchey responded the way a quarterback is supposed to respond. He marched Kentucky 66 yards down the field in the closing minutes, setting up Zouagui’s tying field goal with 4:13 to play. Tied 27-27. Overtime. After trailing by 17 on the road in this building, the Wildcats had forced extra football.

The Gutsy Call

Overtime started with the worst possible script for Kentucky: South Carolina scored first to go up 34-27. The Wildcats needed a touchdown just to stay alive, and Minchey delivered — hitting Henry Boyer from six yards out to make it 34-33.

That is the moment that will live in Kentucky lore. Instead of kicking the extra point and sending the game to a second overtime, Stein went for two. The win, right there, one play, on the road, against a desperate team and 80,000 screaming fans.

Minchey dropped back and threw to tight end Willie Rodriguez in the back of the end zone. Complete. 35-34. Game over. The largest road comeback in program history, sealed by the boldest call of Stein’s young head-coaching career.

“Just an unbelievable effort from our organization, everybody involved,” Stein said afterward, per the Courier-Journal, “we just kept fighting.” He was under no illusions about the aesthetics: “It wasn’t pretty. But man, that’s SEC football on the road. It ain’t gonna be pretty. What matters is you come out with a win. And that’s what we did.”

Sellers’ Monster Game, Wasted

If you want to understand how Kentucky survived, start with what it survived. LaNorris Sellers was magnificent in defeat: 226 passing yards and 147 rushing yards, accounting for 373 of South Carolina’s 458 total yards. In most weeks, that stat line wins going away. On Saturday, it was not enough.

And that loss was a crusher for the Gamecocks. South Carolina fell to 2-3 overall and 0-3 in the SEC — its eighth consecutive conference loss — and head coach Shane Beamer is now under heavy pressure with the season slipping away. A win that Kentucky had no business getting may end up defining the end of someone else’s tenure in Columbia.

Kentucky, meanwhile, is 4-1 with a 2-1 SEC record. Its only loss came to Alabama, now sitting at No. 6. The Wildcats were picked to finish 14th in the SEC in the preseason. Nobody outside Lexington believed in this team. The polls still half-don’t.

What the Analytics Say

The computers are even more skeptical than the AP voters. Per On3’s Sunday reporting, ESPN’s FPI has Kentucky at No. 34 nationally, projecting the Wildcats to finish 6.9-5.1 — essentially a seven-win season — with an 84.3 percent chance of making a bowl game and an 8.5 percent chance of reaching the College Football Playoff. SP+ is lower still, slotting Kentucky at No. 46.

Those numbers say the Wildcats are overachieving, and maybe they are. But they also say the resume is better than the computers want to admit: four wins, one loss to a top-six Alabama team, a 2-1 SEC mark, and now the biggest road comeback in school history. The FPI’s seven-win projection would mean a 3-4 finish from here — hardly a given with the way this team keeps finding ways to win on Saturdays.

The LSU Showdown

All of it sets up a Saturday night in Lexington that Kentucky fans will circle twice. The Wildcats host No. 10 LSU on Oct. 10 at 7:00 p.m. ET on ESPN, with a ranked win — a real, ranked, at-home win — staring them in the face.

Beat the Tigers, and the AP conversation changes completely. No voter is leaving a 5-1 Kentucky with a road OT comeback and a win over a top-ten LSU out of the Top 25. Lose, and the computers get their say — the FPI’s skepticism hardens, the 14th-place preseason pick becomes prophecy, and this magical night in Columbia becomes a footnote instead of a turning point.

Stein’s team has already done something no Kentucky team under Stoops ever did: come back from more than 14 down and win. The next step is doing it against a ranked opponent at home, under the lights, with the polls watching. After Saturday in Columbia, it would be foolish to count them out.

More college football coverage at Previously’s news hub.